A consolidation saving is a forecast of behavior, not a price. Most organizations report it as a price.
What happened
The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported on October 15 that intermediate demand rose more sharply than final demand in September. That means the goods and services businesses buy from each other are getting dearer. Buyers under that pressure often consolidate volume to win better tiers and rebates. The event looks good on paper. The result depends on what happens after the award.
Why the saving leaks after award
The business case assumes spend moves from many suppliers to a few. The price tiers and the rebate are keyed to that move. The reported figure is the new price multiplied by the old volume.
Three things usually break the link:
- The volume stays put. Site managers keep ordering from the local supplier they have used for years. Purchasing cards go to whoever is quickest.
- The thresholds are missed. Tiers and rebates depend on a volume forecast. When the volume is late, the price break never arrives.
- The report stays frozen. The number from the award is repeated in every review, long after the payments have moved on.
None of this is a failure of the negotiation. It is a failure of follow-through, and it happens after the people who negotiated have moved on.
What makes an award stick
- Start from payments. Compare accounts payable by supplier for the twelve months before and the months after the award. The payees tell you what really changed.
- Change the buying channels. Load the new suppliers into the catalog. Tell purchasing card holders where to buy. Block or query invoices from suppliers that were meant to exit.
- Track the thresholds monthly. A tier missed in March is recoverable in April. The same tier missed at the annual review is gone.
- Name an owner for each site. That person answers for old-supplier spend in their location, not only for the total.
One idea to act on
Pick your largest consolidated category. Pull its accounts payable for the last quarter and count the suppliers still being paid. Then check each tier and rebate threshold against the actual volume. Put the gap in front of the owner before the next review.
Read more: